Attorney Bio

Matthew S. Crosby


I like the fight – the fight to hold Big Insurance accountable, the fight to find justice for real people, and the fight to level the playing field for injured consumers. These are the things that motivate me on a daily basis to help my clients get through what is often a very difficult time in their lives.

A New Jersey native, Matthew Crosby was born in Somerville, NJ, and attended Immaculata High School there. After high school, he attended Rider University, graduating in 1990. He pursued his legal education at Widener University School of Law (PA), earning his J.D. in 1993.

Attorney Crosby has been representing clients for 20+ years, bringing decades of insight to each and every case he takes on. He has served as a lecturer for the Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association, the Pennsylvania Bar Institute, and the National Business Institute.

  • 10.0 Superb Avvo Rating

Bar Admissions

  • Pennsylvania
  • New Jersey
  • U.S District Court, Middle District of Pennsylvania
  • U.S. Court of Appeals, Third Circuit


  • Central Pennsylvania Trial Lawyers Association
  • Dauphin County Bar Association
  • Pennsylvania Bar Association
  • Pennsylvania Association for Justice
  • PAJ (Board of Governors, 2000-Present; Executive Committee, 2005-2013; Amicus Curiae Committee, 2004-2013)
  • LAWPAC (Board of Trustees, 2002-2012)
  • American Association for Justice


  • Widener University, J.D., 1993
  • Rider College, B.A., cum laude, 1990

Life Outside the Courtroom

I live in Cumberland County with my wife and two children, who bring me more joy than I ever could imagine. Being raised in New Jersey, I still keep up with my Mets, my Giants and Penn State football.

What Matthew S. Crosby's Clients Have to Say

  • I would like to thank Matt Crosby and the team at Handler, Henning & Rosenberg for resolving our case in a timely fashion. My husband was hit head on while riding his motorcycle. With the extent of his injuries and the amount of time in the trauma center I was quite overwhelmed with calls and decisions. Matt and Nichole took the stress of such an event and helped reduce it drastically. We reached a settlement that was fair for all parties involved. Thank you for everything!

    - A. Pulaski
  • I was always treated with respect and never felt that I was "just a number". Because of my circumstances, the car accident left me in a financial hardship. I needed things to happen quickly without settling for less than I deserved. The staff at Handler, Henning & Rosenberg were very much on top of things and Atty. Crosby never made me doubt that he was working for ME. Everyone was very professional. In the end, I received a settlement that I was MORE than happy with and highly recommend HHR, Atty. Crosby and their staff. Thank you for taking care of me :)

    - Anonymous
  • I was in a car accident and suffered injuries that required physical therapy.I knew early into it that I would need to seek legal representation.I had never gone through this before so I wasn't sure who to call.I saw advertisements on television for Handler Henning and Rosenberg.I decided to call them.I had many Doctor appointments over the course of a year and did not return to work during that time.What I came to find about this law firm,was that they really did care about my well being.They are kind and compassionate but also aggressive about fighting for your rights.Matthew Rosenberg and Jennifer Carl were an amazing team to have on my side.They gave me so much peace of mind.I am now healthy and back to work.If I would need a law firm in the future,I would not hesitate to call Handler, Henning & Rosenberg.Thank you for getting me back on my feet again!

    - Tammie Seiders